The federal judge overseeing Hunter Biden’s tax case in California heard several defense motions to dismiss the charges Wednesday and said afterward that he would issue rulings by April 17.
After a relatively civil start to the hearing, tensions escalated as defense attorney Abbe Lowell and prosecutor Leo Wise bickered and, at times, approached open hostility — ultimately drawing a response from the judge.
Wise repeatedly said Lowell could not make an argument on the merits of the case “other than insulting us” and invoked what he referred to as “the old adage: if you can’t argue the facts, argue the law … and if you can’t argue the law, attack the prosecutors.”
Hunter Biden did not attend the hearing. Special counsel David Weiss has accused Hunter Biden, President Joe Biden’s son, of failing to pay taxes on millions of dollars of income he earned from overseas business ventures.
ALSO READ: “Stay out of Israeli Politics!” Locals Slam Schumer, Biden Over Comments
A sprawling 56-page indictment filed in December described in vivid detail how Hunter Biden, in the throes of drug and alcohol addiction, spent recklessly on women, clothing, and adult entertainment.
“In short, everything but his taxes,” prosecutors wrote.
The back taxes and penalties were subsequently paid in full by a third party, identified by ABC News as Hunter Biden’s attorney and confidant, Kevin Morris. Hunter Biden has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
At Wednesday’s hearing, Judge Scarsi appeared skeptical of several of Hunter Biden’s motions to dismiss, especially the motion to toss counts 1-4 on the basis that the charges were brought in the wrong venue.
Judge Scarsi repeatedly expressed that it was not the court’s role to weigh in on factual matters — that it was a matter for a jury to decide. He told Lowell he was “hamstrung” and “that’s the rub.” The judge also pressed Lowell about his claim that the indictment was the result of a “selective and vindictive” prosecution.
“There doesn’t seem to be any evidence” that efforts by Republicans to pressure special counsel Weiss “influenced the prosecutors’ decision other than the timeline,” Judge Scarsi said — likening the motion to some “smoke” but without sufficient “fire.”
POLL—Should the Government Increase Taxes on the Wealthy To Reduce Economic Inequality?
Lowell conceded that he had no direct evidence but asked the court to investigate the matter further and “connect the dots.” He repeatedly sparred with Judge Scarsi over the significance of a timeline he’d filed — which included allegations made by House Republicans and two IRS whistleblowers in an effort to demonstrate that Weiss buckled to political pressure.
“It’s a timeline, but it’s a pretty juicy timeline,” Lowell said.
Derek Hines, an attorney in Weiss’ office, called Lowell’s timeline theories “absolutely outrageous accusations” and a “fallacy.” Lowell, earlier in the hearing, argued that “the whole” of his eight motions to dismiss the case “is actually greater than the sum of its parts.”
Wise called elements of Hunter Biden’s pleadings “revisionist history” and “effectively fact-free.” The charges, which carry a penalty of up to 17 years in prison, include six misdemeanor charges and three felonies, including alleged tax evasion and filing a false return.
ALSO READ: Biden Approves $60 Million Aid After Baltimore Bridge Collapse
Judge Scarsi has scheduled the trial to begin on June 20. Hunter Biden has also pleaded not guilty to three additional firearm-related charges brought by Weiss’ office in Delaware. That case is expected to go to trial in early June.
You Might Also Like:
Former Diddy Associate Alleges Rapper Yung Miami Was Mogul’s Sex Worker
Ted Cruz Re-election Bid Gets Bad News on Super Tuesday
Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas to Face Lawsuit for Tax Fraud and Ethics Violations
Supreme Court Justices Gorsuch, Thomas, Barrett, and Kavanaugh Sign Dobbs Opinion Without Revision
Newly Unsealed Court Documents Show Mark Zuckerberg Is a Terrifying Boss