Close Menu
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Relationships
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Celebrity Kids
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Disclaimer
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contribute & Advertise with Us
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
GistFestGistFest
  • Entertainment

    “Euphoria: The Final Semester” Trailer Just Dropped — And It Might Be Rue’s Goodbye

    August 7, 2025

    Cancel Culture Fatigue: Has the Internet Finally Hit the Unsubscribe Button?

    August 6, 2025

    The Aesthetic Economy: How Fashion, Filters & Vibes Are Now Bigger Than Talent

    August 5, 2025

    Hollywood’s ‘Summer of Scandals’: PR Nightmares, Leaks & the Rise of the Apology Tour

    August 4, 2025

    “Wakanda Meets Wall Street”: Black Panther Spinoff Series Set in a Futuristic Financial World

    July 31, 2025
  • Lifestyle

    “Euphoria: The Final Semester” Trailer Just Dropped — And It Might Be Rue’s Goodbye

    August 7, 2025

    Cancel Culture Fatigue: Has the Internet Finally Hit the Unsubscribe Button?

    August 6, 2025

    The Aesthetic Economy: How Fashion, Filters & Vibes Are Now Bigger Than Talent

    August 5, 2025

    Hollywood’s ‘Summer of Scandals’: PR Nightmares, Leaks & the Rise of the Apology Tour

    August 4, 2025

    “Wakanda Meets Wall Street”: Black Panther Spinoff Series Set in a Futuristic Financial World

    July 31, 2025
  • Relationships

    “Euphoria: The Final Semester” Trailer Just Dropped — And It Might Be Rue’s Goodbye

    August 7, 2025

    Cancel Culture Fatigue: Has the Internet Finally Hit the Unsubscribe Button?

    August 6, 2025

    The Aesthetic Economy: How Fashion, Filters & Vibes Are Now Bigger Than Talent

    August 5, 2025

    Hollywood’s ‘Summer of Scandals’: PR Nightmares, Leaks & the Rise of the Apology Tour

    August 4, 2025

    “Wakanda Meets Wall Street”: Black Panther Spinoff Series Set in a Futuristic Financial World

    July 31, 2025
  • Tips & Tricks

    “Euphoria: The Final Semester” Trailer Just Dropped — And It Might Be Rue’s Goodbye

    August 7, 2025

    Cancel Culture Fatigue: Has the Internet Finally Hit the Unsubscribe Button?

    August 6, 2025

    The Aesthetic Economy: How Fashion, Filters & Vibes Are Now Bigger Than Talent

    August 5, 2025

    Hollywood’s ‘Summer of Scandals’: PR Nightmares, Leaks & the Rise of the Apology Tour

    August 4, 2025

    “Wakanda Meets Wall Street”: Black Panther Spinoff Series Set in a Futuristic Financial World

    July 31, 2025
  • Celebrity Kids

    Brody Jenner Ties the Knot With Tia Blanco in Dreamy Malibu Ceremony — See the Intimate Moments

    July 17, 2025

    Madison LeCroy Welcomes Baby No. 2 — the Heartwarming Story Behind the Name

    July 9, 2025

    Ariana Zolciak Supports Kim Zolciak and Siblings Amid Ongoing Money Issues

    July 7, 2025

    Sofia Richie and Elliot Grainge Revisit Lavish Wedding Venue Amid Backlash Over Cheating Rumors

    June 24, 2025

    Exes Megan Fox and MGK Unveil Their Baby Girl’s Name Following ‘Celestial Seed’ Mix-Up

    June 20, 2025
Subscribe
GistFestGistFest
Home » Why Do People Think the Supreme Court’s New Ethics Code Is Wrong?
News

Why Do People Think the Supreme Court’s New Ethics Code Is Wrong?

FeyisayoBy FeyisayoNovember 24, 20235 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit Telegram Email
A picture of the Supreme Court
Source: Pinterest
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

The Supreme Court recently revealed a new set of ethics codes. However, the public is not happy with the changes made due to the usage of some words. 

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • Introduction of Supreme Court’s New Ethics Code
  • The Major Difference in the Supreme Court’s New Ethics Code 
  • What is Wrong With the New Ethics Code?
  • Lack of Transparency of the Supreme Court
  • Recusal Standards for Federal Judges 
  • The Supreme Court’s Recusal Standard
  • Code Parallels with Lower Federal Judges
  • Lack of Public Trust Due to Controversies
  • The Impact of the Controversies on the New Code
  • Critics Question Code’s Effectiveness
  • Concerns About the Accountability of the Supreme Court
  • Is the Supreme Court’s New Code a PR Stunt?
A picture of the Supreme Court
Source: Pinterest

Introduction of Supreme Court’s New Ethics Code

The Supreme Court recently introduced its new code of ethics, mirroring the rules established for lower federal judges. As with past judges, the regulation aims to govern the conduct of Supreme Court justices and guide their ethical considerations.

A judge using a gavel
Source: Pinterest

Therefore, this new ethics code serves as a strict guideline for the judges that sit in the Supreme Court of Justice. 

The Major Difference in the Supreme Court’s New Ethics Code 

Since the beginning, the Supreme Court has always been consistent with the terminologies used in its codes. The word “shall” is used constantly when setting its rules. 

Some of the Supreme Court judges
Source: MSN

However, a notable aspect of this new code is its consistent use of the term “should” instead of the more assertive “shall” found in the rules for lower federal judges. 

What is Wrong With the New Ethics Code?

Due to the ‘softened’ language in the new code, the public and other bodies have raised suspicions about the validity of the code. Using “should instead of “shall” has implications for the level of obligation justices feel toward the outlined ethical standards.

A picture of the US Supreme court
Source: Pinterest

While the difference looks simple on paper, it holds a lot of weight because it is not as assertive as the former “shall.”

Lack of Transparency of the Supreme Court

Another significant concern arises from the absence of an external body tasked with enforcing the code’s provisions. While lower federal judges have more transparent mechanisms for accountability, Supreme Court justices rely only on internal ethical self-regulation.

A judge’s gavel
Source: Pinterest

Therefore, the use of the less assertive “shall” allows for a lot of freedom and manipulation if the judges do not follow the rules. 

Recusal Standards for Federal Judges 

The standards for recusal in lower federal courts are simple and explicit. The code states that judges “shall” recuse themselves when facing cases involving friends or family members, ensuring impartiality.

A picture of a Federal Court House
Source: Pinterest

Therefore, no judge with family or friendly ties to a plaintiff or defendant can sit on the jury. This law was put in place to prevent bias towards the parties involved. 

The Supreme Court’s Recusal Standard

In contrast, the Supreme Court’s court code does not state that the judge “shall” recuse themselves in these cases. Instead, it says that Justices “should” recuse themselves in situations where their impartiality might be reasonably questioned. 

A Supreme Court from inside
Source: Pinterest

This change of words leaves room for interpretation, and one can argue it doesn’t mean the same thing when “shall” is used. 

Code Parallels with Lower Federal Judges

The Supreme Court’s code shares many similarities with the ethical guidelines for lower federal judges. However, subtle but crucial differences emerge in language choices and standards of conduct, clearly distinguishing between both parties. 

A picture of a judge’s seat
Source: Pinterest

Therefore, it is difficult for the public to put their faith in the court when they draw parallels that benefit only its members. 

Lack of Public Trust Due to Controversies

The public has a distrustful perception of the Supreme Court judges. This is a result of several stories in 2023 about their misconduct while in power. 

The judges of the Supreme Court
Source: MSN

For example, Justice Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito frequently accept lavish gifts from high-ranking officials. Again, a story broke earlier about the other justices rubbing shoulders with millionaire lawyers at exclusive events. 

The Impact of the Controversies on the New Code

As stories like Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s book promotions unfolded, the public expected the new code to respond directly to these controversies. 

A Court house from inside
Source: Pinterest

Therefore, the new code was supposed to be an excellent way to check the judges by putting firm rules in place. Instead, this new code leaves a lot to change, and all nine justices of the Supreme Court have agreed to a code of ethics.

Critics Question Code’s Effectiveness

As expected, critics have much to say about this new ethics code. Groups like Accountable.US pointed out the potential limitations of the Supreme Court’s code. 

A picture of a judge's seat
Source: Pinterest

They believe this new code is not a precise or effective enforcement mechanism for the judges. 

Furthermore, they agree with the general public that the difference between the rules may cause many problems in the near future.

Concerns About the Accountability of the Supreme Court

This new selection of rules in the ethics code leaves a lot of room for unaccountability. As the public already doesn’t trust the judges, it seems deliberate to avoid repercussions when they break rules. 

A picture of a court house
Source: Pinterest

In addition, the autonomy of power that the Supreme Court judges have is only to their advantage. If they are truly corrupt, the government has a big problem on their hands. 

Is the Supreme Court’s New Code a PR Stunt?

Many people concluded that this new code of ethics is only a PR stunt. The skeptics argue that it lacks a precise enforcement mechanism, so it could be perceived more as a public relations move than a substantive commitment to ethical governance. 

Symbols of justice
Source: Pinterest

However, there are no actual indications of this being a PR stunt, and the code still stands till today. 

Law Supreme Court
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Previous ArticleHere are the 12 Easiest Countries To Move To As an American
Next Article New Orleans Mayor Gets Backlash For Spending Almost $30,000 on Flights

Related Posts

Entertainment

Pride & Prejudice Returns to Theaters in India for 20th Anniversary—Don’t Miss the Iconic Love Story

July 23, 2025
Lifestyle

Inside the Breaking Point That Ended Gwyneth Paltrow and Madonna’s Friendship, Says New Biography

July 21, 2025
News

Kelly Osbourne Engaged to Sid Wilson During Ozzy’s Black Sabbath Farewell

July 10, 2025
Latest Posts

“Euphoria: The Final Semester” Trailer Just Dropped — And It Might Be Rue’s Goodbye

August 7, 2025

Cancel Culture Fatigue: Has the Internet Finally Hit the Unsubscribe Button?

August 6, 2025

The Aesthetic Economy: How Fashion, Filters & Vibes Are Now Bigger Than Talent

August 5, 2025

Hollywood’s ‘Summer of Scandals’: PR Nightmares, Leaks & the Rise of the Apology Tour

August 4, 2025

“Wakanda Meets Wall Street”: Black Panther Spinoff Series Set in a Futuristic Financial World

July 31, 2025

From Albums to Algorithms: Why Every Artist Is Fighting for a TikTok Moment in 2025

July 30, 2025

Nostalgia Never Dies: “Twilight” TV Series in the Works — But Do We Need It?

July 29, 2025

Beyoncé’s Cowboy Carter Era: How She’s Redefining Country Music One Boot at a Time

July 28, 2025
About
About

We’re a news, entertainment and lifestyle hub that is dedicated to giving you quality insight on the latest lifestyle news, movie and TV news, celebrity news and lots more.

Contact us: info@gistfest.com

MOST POPULAR

Alina Nikitina: Everything We Know About the Russian Model

October 4, 2023

Jacob’s Ladder Piercing: All You Need To Know

July 21, 2023

Jennifer Rauchet: Inside the Life of Pete Hegseth’s Wife

August 30, 2023

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox!

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Disclaimer
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contribute & Advertise with Us
© 2025 GistFest. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.