A federal judge has halted the new healthcare policy of the Biden administration that would permit the US healthcare service providers to refuse treatment based on the patient’s gender identity.
This rule was sold as an anti-discrimination healthcare policy that would have enabled federal funding to reach trans individuals pursuing hormones, surgery, and other gender-affirming services.
The Biden Rule
The Biden administration overturned a Trump administration regulation in April 2024. By announcing a new rule that would safeguard LGBT Americans seeking medical treatment.
Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra stated that at the time “today’s rule is a giant step forward for this country. As it is towards a more equitable and inclusive health care system. Americans across the country now have a clear way to act on their rights against discrimination when they visit the doctor. Also, talk with their health plan, or engage with health programs run by HHS.”
Ruling of the Judge
The decision is hailed by the proponents of the rights of the transgender. Who for a long time considered the act of the denial of care to transgenders on the grounds of gender as a violation of their human rights.
The judgment frustrates the Biden presidency’s attempt to revoke the rights of the LGBTQ+ community.
Controversy About the Restrictions
Certain sections of the rule clashed against the recently established state legislation. Even though it was being developed by a federal agency.
Transgender youth cannot receive various sorts of gender-affirming care in more than 20 states due to restrictions or complete bans.
ALSO READ: Donald Trump Reacts to Controversial Picture of Pope Francis and Joe Biden
Shift in the Rule
In its defense, the Biden administration argued that such a move would enable healthcare providers to exercise their religious freedom. Also, conscience when making decisions about patient care.
However, the opponents claimed that the shift in such rules was just an act of prejudice against transgender people.
Some of the Negative Impacts
Healthcare providers could have refused treatment. According to the new regulation, healthcare providers could have also denied medical treatment to a trans person on grounds of gender identity.
This ranged from weaning out treatment of terminal illnesses such as HIV and cancer to denying specific treatment that is essential for the treatment of trans-sexuals including hormone replacement therapy.
POLL—Should the U.S. Government Create a Path to Citizenship for Undocumented Immigrants?
The Change Violates Several Civil Rights Laws
Critics claimed that the regulation change was in clear violation of civil rights statutes. The ACA, and the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
They contended that depriving transgender people of access to healthcare due to their gender status as male or female is discrimination. This is on grounds of gender and infringes on the individuals’ rights as human beings.
Future Implications
This verdict may affect other aspects of the lives of the people of the LGBTQ+ community besides their health. For the same reason, it could also affect the government’s ability to remove the rights of the LGBTQ+ community in other domains like education and employment.
Activists and supporters rejoiced in the outcome stating that it was a huge win for the trans people and everyone’s rights.
Biden Team Vows to Fight
The Biden administration vowed to reverse that decision, noting that it will defend its right to implement its healthcare policy.
About the ruling, a White House spokesperson remarked. “We are disappointed the court has ruled in that way and remain determined to have our way on our healthcare policy.
Transgender Individuals Remain Ambiguous
The effect of this judgment of the judge on the Transgenders has yet to be seen.
However, this may mean that the Biden administration may have to appeal the decision and maintain its healthcare policy. Or it may have to come up with another policy that complies with federal law.
WATCH: Powell Warns US Is on an “Unsustainable Fiscal Path”
Generalizations Made About the Healthcare Industry
It therefore means that the consequence of the determination to be made by the judge will affect the whole healthcare industry.
This could cause more confusion and uncertainty as to what is legal and what is not regarding the treatment of patients within this population.
Online Reaction
Some internet users blamed the recent decisions made by the conservative majority Supreme Court for this reaction.
“During Trump’s reign, right-wing justices were jam-packed into every possible position in government. You can thank (or hate) the Heritage Foundation and the Federalists Society for that,” a Reddit user commented.
A Win for Supporters
This judgment can be seen as a win for the supporters of the rights of trans people. Also, a loss for the pro-LGBTQ+ president of the United States, Joe Biden.
However, the impact of the decision on transgender individuals and the healthcare industry remains unclear. This is just one battle in a much larger war over human rights and discrimination in America.
You Might Also Like:
Starbucks Announces New Pairings Menu
Democrat Lawmakers Slam Supreme Court Ruling on Trump Immunity
Dermatologists Reveal the Benefits and side effects of using retinol and retinoids
Poll in Two Critical Swing States Shows Trump a Positive Sign
Remember Barbara Kavovit from RHONY? Here’s What She’s Up to Now
